The Messaging Mistake That Sends Your Best Prospects to Competitors
Every week, tax professionals tell me the same frustrating story. Prospects reach out, they have a conversation, and then it becomes clear the caller wants something completely different from what the practitioner actually provides.
An EA who focuses exclusively on IRS collections work spends twenty minutes on the phone with someone who just needs a Schedule C prepared. A CPA who built an entire practice around offer in compromise cases keeps getting inquiries about bookkeeping services. A tax attorney specializing in Appeals representation fields calls from people who want help forming an LLC.
These conversations aren’t just awkward—they represent a fundamental breakdown in how you’re communicating with the marketplace.
The Disconnect Between What You Say and What They Hear
When prospects misunderstand your services, the instinct is to blame them for not paying attention. But the responsibility actually falls on us as practitioners. If multiple people are drawing the wrong conclusions about what we do, our communications are sending mixed signals.
Marketing expert Dan Kennedy has long emphasized that alignment between your message and your intended audience determines whether your marketing efforts produce results or waste resources. When that alignment breaks down, you end up attracting people you cannot help while simultaneously becoming invisible to those who desperately need your expertise.
This dynamic is particularly problematic in the tax resolution space. Taxpayers facing IRS collections actions need specialized help. They’re dealing with revenue officers, facing bank levies, watching their paychecks get garnished. These people will pay premium fees—$5,000, $10,000, $15,000 or more—for someone who can solve their specific problem.
But if your marketing looks identical to every other tax practitioner in your area, these high-value prospects have no way to identify you as the specialist they need. They scroll past your content, ignore your ads, and hire someone else—often someone less qualified but whose messaging spoke directly to their situation.
Why Smart Practitioners Make This Error
The confusion usually stems from one of several patterns I’ve observed repeatedly among tax professionals.
Some practitioners cast too wide a net intentionally. They worry that narrowing their message will cost them opportunities, so they keep their communications vague and general. “Full-service tax help” feels safer than “IRS debt resolution for business owners.” But broad positioning actually reduces response because it fails to signal expertise to anyone with a specific problem.
Others let their interests bleed into their marketing. You might find cryptocurrency taxation fascinating, or enjoy staying current on estate planning developments. There’s nothing wrong with professional curiosity. But when your resolution-focused marketing channels feature content about topics unrelated to IRS collections and examinations, you muddy the waters for prospects trying to understand what you actually do.
Many practitioners write for the wrong audience entirely. Content that would impress colleagues at a professional conference often falls flat with distressed taxpayers. Technical precision matters in your work product, but your marketing needs to connect emotionally with people who are frightened, embarrassed, and searching for someone who understands their predicament.
Finally, some tax professionals share valuable information consistently but never clearly articulate their offer. They educate without inviting engagement. Prospects consume the content, appreciate the insights, and then hire someone else because they never understood that the content creator was available to help them directly.
The Energy Equation Nobody Talks About
Beyond lost revenue, messaging misalignment creates a hidden drain on your capacity. Every mismatched inquiry consumes time—time spent on phone calls that go nowhere, emails explaining what you don’t do, mental energy recovering from conversations that feel like dead ends.
Tax practitioners already face significant demands on their attention. Case development, IRS correspondence, client communications, continuing education, practice management—the list never ends. Adding unnecessary friction through unclear positioning makes an already demanding profession even more exhausting.
When your message precisely matches your market, something shifts. The people who contact you already understand what you offer. Consultations start from a place of alignment rather than explanation. Conversion rates improve because you’re speaking with qualified prospects rather than random inquiries. Your entire practice operates with less friction.
Evaluating Your Current Communications
Taking an honest inventory of your marketing materials often reveals gaps you hadn’t noticed. Consider examining your communications through several lenses.
Start with language clarity. Are you describing your services in terms that make immediate sense to someone with no tax background? A taxpayer who just received a Final Notice of Intent to Levy doesn’t know what “collections representation” means. They want to know if you can stop the IRS from taking their money.
Look at audience alignment. Read your recent emails, social posts, or blog content and ask who would find this relevant. If the honest answer is “other tax professionals” rather than “taxpayers in trouble with the IRS,” your content may be impressing peers rather than attracting clients.
Examine your calls to action. When you invite prospects to take a next step, is that step clearly connected to your actual service? Asking someone to “schedule a call” means little. Asking them to “schedule a free case evaluation to discuss options for your IRS balance” communicates exactly what will happen.
Check your offer visibility. From any point where a prospect might encounter you—social media profile, website homepage, email signature, directory listing—can they quickly identify what problem you solve and how to engage you? If finding your core offer requires detective work, prospects will abandon the search.
Consider your visual and tonal consistency. Do your images, design elements, and writing style reinforce serious professional expertise in a specific area? Or do they create ambiguity about whether you’re a generalist, a preparer, a bookkeeper, or a resolution specialist?
The Compound Effect of Precision
Practitioners often resist narrowing their message because limitation feels like loss. But the opposite proves true in practice. Specificity attracts rather than repels.
When your communications clearly identify the problem you solve and the person you solve it for, qualified prospects recognize themselves in your message. They think, “This person is talking about my exact situation.” That recognition creates connection, and connection drives action.
Simultaneously, people who aren’t a fit recognize that reality before consuming your time. They look elsewhere for help with their tax preparation, their bookkeeping, their entity formation—all the services you don’t provide and don’t want to provide.
Your referral network also benefits from messaging clarity. When another professional can easily articulate what you do—”She helps business owners who owe the IRS significant money”—they send you appropriate referrals rather than random tax questions.
The tax resolution specialists building thriving practices share one common characteristic: prospects immediately understand what they do. No confusion, no explanation required, no wasted conversations.
Examine your marketing this week with fresh eyes. If a taxpayer desperately needing resolution help encountered your content, would they instantly recognize you as the right person to call?
If you’re not certain the answer is yes, your message needs work.
____________________________________________________
Here’s to working smarter, not harder!
And a brighter future for your tax practice!
If you want to know more consider joining the Tax Resolution Academy® by clicking this link to earn your Certified Taxpayer Representative™ (CTR™) certification
I hope this helps.
If you have any questions, please reach out to us.
I would love to hear your thoughts, challenges, and successes in writing your very own book.
Have a GREAT day,
Cordially,
Dan
Dan Henn, CPA, CTR™
Co-Founder, Tax Resolution Academy®
Managing Member
Tax Pro Academy, LLC
P.S. Want to learn more about the Tax Resolution Academy®, go to https://community.taxresolutionacademy.com.
P.P.S. Check out our CPE classes here! Click the link to Follow our page and you will be notified when we release new classes.
